본문 바로가기
디센트법률사무소 로고

365일 24시 전담팀 대응

간편 상담 신청

미디어센터 법률칼럼
A mint-colored smartphone and magnifying glass illustrating selective forensic examination and participation rights

Limits on the Analysis of KakaoTalk Messages, Photos and Deleted Data, and the Lawfulness of Search and Seizure Procedures

Mobile phone forensics is a frequent concern for people preparing for police questioning in a criminal case or whose phones have been seized. Reports that investigators can examine KakaoTalk conversations, photos, videos, internet search histories and deleted files can cause considerable uncertainty.

Digital forensics is an investigative technique for collecting and analyzing electronic information stored on a device. However, the information that forensic technology can recover must be distinguished from the information that investigators may lawfully search for and seize under Korean law.

1. Analytical Scope and Legal Limits of Mobile Phone Forensics

Mobile phone forensics involves collecting and analyzing electronic information stored on a phone. Messages, photographs, call logs and other information relevant to a case may be examined. More generally, digital forensics uses data left on digital devices or storage media to establish facts relevant to an investigation.

Typical categories of information include:

  • KakaoTalk conversations, text messages and other communications
  • Photographs, videos and associated file information
  • Call logs and contacts
  • Internet access and search histories
  • App usage information and other data remaining on the device
  • Residual information from deleted files

Not all of this information will necessarily be accessible. The phone model, operating system, encryption, the way each app stores data and the condition of retained records can affect the scope of analysis.

Technical extractability does not mean that investigators may seize everything. Article 106(3) of Korea’s Criminal Procedure Act generally requires the scope of electronic information to be specified and that information to be printed or copied when storage media are subject to seizure. Article 219 applies this principle to police searches and seizures.

The relevant questions are therefore both what information can be found and whether that information relates to the alleged offense under investigation.

2. Recoverability of Deleted Conversations and Photos

Some deleted KakaoTalk conversations or photographs may be recoverable, but not all deleted data can be restored. Deleting data from a phone does not necessarily erase every related record immediately. Information may remain on the device, in another storage area or in backups. Actual recoverability depends on storage methods and how the data have been processed since deletion.

Limits on KakaoTalk Conversation Recovery

If parts of a conversation or related files remain, they may be identifiable. This does not mean that every deleted message can be restored. Results depend on the app’s storage methods, available backups, encryption and the material remaining on the device.

Even where the content itself cannot be recovered, other records or conversation copies retained by the other participant may establish relevant facts.

Recovery of Deleted Photos and Videos

Photographs and videos may also be partly accessible through residual data or backups. Recovery may be difficult where files have been overwritten or encryption creates technical limitations.

Deletion alone does not establish that investigators can no longer obtain the information. Equally, it is inaccurate to suggest that forensic analysis always restores all deleted material.

Procedural Safeguards During Deleted File Recovery

Recovery of deleted files and analysis of encrypted data can themselves form part of an electronic search and seizure whose lawfulness must be examined. The Supreme Court has confirmed the importance of protecting the participation rights of the person subject to the search and seizure or their counsel during digital evidence analysis, including deleted file recovery and decryption (Supreme Court Order 2024Mo418, October 16, 2026).

The process by which data are recovered and analyzed is therefore important, as well as the material ultimately obtained.

3. Warrant Scope and the Principle of Selective Seizure

A search and seizure warrant does not authorize unrestricted examination of every item on a phone. As a rule, investigators must remain within the warrant’s terms and target electronic information related to the alleged offense.

Article 215(2) of the Criminal Procedure Act requires a warrant issued by a judge for a judicial police officer’s search and seizure in a criminal investigation, limited to items recognized as related to the case. Electronic information should generally be identified and selected within the authorized scope. Seizure of a phone does not automatically make every conversation, photograph and file on it subject to seizure.

Strict Interpretation of the Items Specified in a Warrant

The wording describing the items to be seized must be interpreted strictly. The Supreme Court held that, absent special circumstances, a warrant cannot authorize seizure of electronic information stored on a phone if that information is not included among the specified items (Supreme Court Order 2024Mo2020, September 25, 2024).

The warrant in that case referred to information processing devices such as computers and laptops, and storage media such as USB drives and external hard drives. The issue was whether electronic information on a phone fell within that wording. A reference to storage media alone does not necessarily include information stored on a mobile phone.

Restrictions on Unrelated Information and Its Subsequent Handling

Investigators generally may not seize information unrelated to the alleged offense at their discretion. The Supreme Court held that copying or printing information stored on a phone without distinguishing its relevance to the allegations generally constitutes unlawful seizure.

It also found unlawful the continued retention of unrelated information after completion of the search and seizure, without deletion, disposal or return, and its examination to investigate a new alleged offense (Supreme Court Judgment 2022Do11923, August 14, 2025). The decision illustrates the requirement to select electronic information by its relevance to the alleged offense.

Exceptionally, removal of the storage medium or a complete copy for off-site analysis may be permitted where on-site selection is impossible or would make achieving the purpose of seizure substantially difficult. Subsequent searching and selection must still comply with procedural safeguards.

SituationKey Legal ConsiderationRecords and Details to Check
Phone data expressly included in the warrantWarrant wording and relevance to the alleged offenseSpecified items, allegations and information scope
Phone data not clearly includedStrict interpretation of the warrantSpecific description of the items to be seized
Only case-related messages selectedLawfulness of the selection procedureSearch methods, selection and participation rights
All data copied without a relevance distinctionNeed for exceptional complete copying and subsequent selectionReason for copying and treatment of unrelated information
Information about another offense discoveredOriginal warrant scope and a separate lawful collection basisHow it was discovered and any additional warrant

The lawfulness of a search and seizure depends on the warrant’s terms, the circumstances of execution and the electronic information analysis process, considered together. How information was obtained is as important as what forensic analysis revealed.

Search Scope for a Voluntarily Submitted Phone

Seizure under a warrant must be distinguished from seizure of a phone voluntarily submitted by its owner, possessor or another relevant person. Even where Article 218 of the Criminal Procedure Act permits seizure following voluntary submission, handing over the phone does not by itself authorize a comprehensive search of all its data. The reasons and circumstances of submission, the submitter’s expressed intention and relevance to the case should be examined, and submission confirmations and related records should be preserved.

4. Participation Rights During Digital Evidence Analysis

In an electronic search and seizure, participation rights of the person subject to the procedure or their counsel must be protected. These rights are relevant during digital evidence analysis as well as final file selection.

Articles 121 and 122 of the Criminal Procedure Act address participation in warrant execution and advance notice. Article 219 applies the relevant provisions to police searches and seizures. Investigators must generally provide an opportunity to participate, although statutory exceptions may apply, including an express intention not to participate or circumstances requiring urgent action.

Participation During Analysis Before Final Selection

Participation only at final selection does not necessarily satisfy the safeguards required throughout the analysis. On October 16, 2026, the Supreme Court considered a search and seizure involving electronic information on a laptop and other devices where participation in digital evidence analysis had not been allowed.

After copies of the storage media were made, investigators recovered deleted files and decrypted data without giving the person subject to seizure or their counsel an opportunity to participate in that analysis. The Court treated digital evidence analysis as an important step in defining the content and scope of the information to be seized, rather than a merely technical preparatory process.

The Court found a violation serious enough to render the overall procedure unlawful, taking into account, among other matters, the repeated requests to participate throughout the search and seizure (Supreme Court Order 2024Mo418, October 16, 2026). Although the case concerned a laptop, it is relevant when examining participation rights during analysis of electronic information on mobile phones and other devices.

A participation rights violation does not automatically result in cancellation of the seizure or exclusion of evidence in every case. The nature and seriousness of the violation require separate assessment.

5. Responses to an Unlawful Search and Seizure

If mobile phone search and seizure procedures were unlawful, possible responses include challenging the relevant disposition and contesting the admissibility of the electronic evidence. An allegation of a forensic procedural defect alone does not automatically exclude evidence. The particular rule breached, the seriousness of the breach and its connection with the evidence obtained require examination.

Warrant and Seizure Inventory Review

The starting point is to establish the legal basis and actual scope of the search and seizure. Relevant details include:

  • The alleged offense described in the warrant
  • The phone and categories of electronic information subject to seizure
  • How and when investigators obtained the phone
  • Whether a complete copy was created and the reasons for doing so
  • The inventory of electronic information ultimately seized

Article 129 of the Criminal Procedure Act requires an inventory of seized items to be prepared and delivered to the owner, possessor, custodian or another equivalent person.

Review of Participation Safeguards

The methods used to analyze the phone after seizure should be checked. Particular attention is required to participation safeguards during removal of storage media, creation of copies, data analysis, and searching for and selecting relevant information.

Relevant records include notices of analysis schedules, communications expressing an intention to participate and evidence of whether an actual opportunity to participate was provided.

Unlawfully Obtained Evidence and Admissibility

Article 308-2 of the Criminal Procedure Act provides that evidence collected without lawful procedure is inadmissible. The admissibility of material may therefore be disputed where investigators collected information beyond the authorized scope or seriously infringed participation rights.

The assessment requires consideration of the specific procedural violation and any exceptional circumstances. If other evidence was obtained on the basis of unlawfully collected electronic information, the admissibility of that derivative evidence also requires separate review.

Quasi-Appeal Against a Seizure Disposition

Where the search and seizure disposition itself is considered unlawful, a quasi-appeal under Article 417 of the Criminal Procedure Act may be considered. This is a procedure for requesting that a court cancel or modify certain dispositions by investigative authorities.

Filing a quasi-appeal does not guarantee cancellation. The actual procedure, the stage reached and the alleged grounds of unlawfulness must be examined when determining the response.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can the Police Read All My KakaoTalk Conversations if I Submit My Phone?

Submission alone does not authorize an unrestricted search of every conversation. Seizure under a warrant must be distinguished from voluntary submission, and the scope of submission and information searches must be identified. The legal assessment depends on how the phone was submitted and how investigators actually collected its data.

Can Information About Another Offense Discovered During Forensic Analysis Be Used in an Investigation?

Discovery of information about another offense does not permit its unrestricted seizure or use under the original warrant. The original search scope, the circumstances of discovery and any separate lawful basis for collection must be examined.

Is All the Evidence Inadmissible if I Could Not Participate in the Forensic Analysis?

Not necessarily. The nature and extent of the infringement, the importance of the affected stage within the overall procedure and any special circumstances must be considered together. Inability to participate does not, by itself, automatically make all the evidence inadmissible.

When Can a Phone Seized by the Police Be Returned?

The timing depends on whether continued seizure is necessary. Article 218-2 of the Criminal Procedure Act permits a request for return or provisional return before indictment where continued seizure is considered unnecessary, including where copies have been secured. A request for return may therefore be considered even before the investigation is completed.

Key Considerations for a Response

Forensic analysis may cover KakaoTalk conversations, photographs, call logs and other electronic information, but it neither guarantees recovery of all data nor permits unlimited seizure. The warrant’s scope, relevance to the alleged offense, selection procedures and participation safeguards are central considerations.

If a phone has been seized, the warrant and seizure inventory should be reviewed and records showing how forensic analysis was conducted should be organized.

Official Sources and References

National Law Information Center — Criminal Procedure Act, Article 106

National Law Information Center — Criminal Procedure Act, Articles 121, 122 and 129

National Law Information Center — Criminal Procedure Act, Article 215

National Law Information Center — Criminal Procedure Act, Article 218

National Law Information Center — Criminal Procedure Act, Article 218-2

National Law Information Center — Criminal Procedure Act, Article 219

National Law Information Center — Criminal Procedure Act, Article 308-2

National Law Information Center — Criminal Procedure Act, Article 417

Supreme Court Order 2024Mo418, October 16, 2026 — Official Decision

Supreme Court Order 2024Mo2020, September 25, 2024 — National Law Information Center

Supreme Court Judgment 2022Do11923, August 14, 2025 — National Law Information Center