Seized Virtual Assets: Requests for Return and Provisional Return
Standards for requesting the return or provisional return of virtual assets seized during a criminal investigation
When coins in a personal wallet are transferred to an investigative authority's wallet or an exchange account is frozen during a search and seizure in a virtual asset case, business funds remain tied up and price volatility risk persists throughout the investigation. The Criminal Procedure Act provides that items no longer requiring seizure must be returned upon request by the owner or other eligible persons, even before indictment.
1. Return and Provisional Return
Return releases the seizure and hands the item back. Provisional return keeps the seizure in effect while allowing the owner or other eligible person to hold and use the item on an interim basis.
2. Request Procedure During the Investigation
Article 218-2(1) of the Criminal Procedure Act requires seized items that no longer need to be held to be returned or provisionally returned before indictment upon request by the owner, possessor, custodian, or person who submitted them, and Article 218-2(2) allows the requester to apply to the court for a return or provisional return decision if the prosecutor refuses. The same procedure applies where the judicial police seized the item. During the investigation, a request must be made under Article 218-2 rather than Article 133.
3. Issues Specific to Seized Virtual Assets
| Issue | Points to Review |
|---|---|
| Exchange account freeze vs. wallet transfer | Whether the freeze is based on a seizure or the exchange's own measure, which determines the counterparty and method of return |
| Proof of ownership | Source of purchase funds, wallet address management history, accounting records |
| Price volatility | Specific explanation of loss risk from prolonged seizure |
4. Responding to a Refusal
Investigators may refuse return on the grounds that the assets are needed as evidence or may be subject to confiscation or collection of equivalent value. Where return is refused even though continued seizure is unnecessary, the requester may apply to the court for a decision; where the search and seizure procedure itself was unlawful, a quasi-appeal under Article 417 of the Criminal Procedure Act should be considered. Preservation orders for confiscation or collection are subject to separate challenge procedures.
Because the explanation of ownership in a return request must be consistent with later statements, it should be developed together with the overall defense strategy for the case.
5. Implications for Companies
Recovering seized virtual assets requires designing the legal basis for the request, proof of ownership, and the defense strategy together. Companies should first secure the seizure list, wallet addresses and transaction records, and evidence of the source of purchase funds, and consider requesting provisional return before losses grow.
Relevant Laws
Korea Law Information Center — Criminal Procedure Act, Articles 218-2 and 417

