본문 바로가기
디센트법률사무소 로고

24/7 Dedicated Support

Quick consultation request

MEDIA Blogs
Illustration of a file folder and split token coins representing investor fraud complaints against a token project team

Timing of fraudulent intent, aggravated penalties by amount of gain, and materials for the investigation

When a token price falls sharply, investors who suffered losses may file fraud complaints against the project team, citing the white paper, roadmap, announcements, and community statements as evidence of deception. A price decline or project delay alone does not constitute fraud, but criminal liability may arise if the explanations given at the time of fundraising differed from the actual circumstances.

Depending on the alleged amount, aggravated punishment under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes and violations of the Virtual Asset User Protection Act may be considered together. The standard for fraudulent intent, calculation of the gain, fund flow records, and the response at each stage of the investigation should be organized together.

1. Time Point for Assessing Fraud

Fraud under the Criminal Act is established where a person deceives another and thereby receives property or obtains a pecuniary advantage. In token sales and fundraising, the issue is whether the team's explanations constituted deception that induced the investment decision.

Fraudulent intent is assessed as of the time the investment was received. Courts have determined intent by considering the objective circumstances at that time, including financial capacity, the status of the business, and the use of funds. The key question is whether the team received investments without any intention or ability to carry out the project; a later failure due to market conditions does not by itself constitute fraud. Conversely, even if the project partly proceeded, misrepresenting key facts at the time of fundraising may be found to be deception.

2. Review of White Paper and Announcement Statements

Investigators compare the white paper, roadmap, investment materials, Telegram and Discord announcements, and team interviews to determine whether any explanation differed from the actual circumstances.

Issues may include whether unconfirmed exchange listings or partnerships were presented as confirmed, whether team token holdings or lock-up terms were misstated, and whether the use of raised funds was described differently from actual use.

Statements presented as goals or plans are distinguished from statements asserted as facts. Even where the term planned was used, a problem may arise if the team knew at the time that realization was nearly impossible. Revision histories of announcements and internal meeting records show what information the team had at the time.

RecordsPoints to Confirm
White paper and roadmapDrafting dates, revision history, distinction between plans and facts
Announcements and community statementsStatements on listings, partnerships, and token supply, and their basis
Use of fundsActual use of raised funds and wallet and account records
Internal recordsMeeting minutes, outsourcing contracts, development progress materials

3. Aggravated Penalties by Gain and Application of the Virtual Asset User Protection Act

Where the gain obtained through fraud is KRW 500 million or more, aggravated penalties apply under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes: life imprisonment or imprisonment of at least five years for KRW 5 billion or more, and imprisonment of at least three years for KRW 500 million or more but less than KRW 5 billion, with an optional fine up to the amount of the gain.

The gain is calculated based on the property or benefit obtained through the offense, not the total losses claimed by complainants. Whether harm to multiple investors is treated as one offense or as separate offenses may change the applicable provision, so the calculation method should be reviewed from the outset.

The Virtual Asset User Protection Act prohibits using false statements or representations on material matters in connection with virtual asset transactions to obtain pecuniary gain. Violations are punishable by imprisonment of at least one year or a fine of three to five times the gain. Even where a matter begins as a fraud complaint, violations of this Act and confiscation or collection of criminal proceeds may be considered together.

4. Organization of Fund Flows and Project Records

Whether raised funds were actually used for the stated purposes, such as development, marketing, liquidity provision, and operating expenses, is important evidence of intent. Inflow and outflow records for each wallet address, corporate account transactions, outsourcing contracts, and work products should be organized together.

If large sales occurred from team or affiliated wallets shortly after listing, the team should be able to explain the circumstances and compliance with lock-up terms separately.

Statements made while contacting complainants individually or repeatedly offering explanations in the community may later conflict with formal statements and become unfavorable evidence. The official position should be consolidated after confirming the facts. Deleting records or hastily moving wallet assets may lead investigators to suspect concealment of evidence or assets.

5. Response by Investigation Stage and Restitution Negotiations

After a complaint is filed, the police commonly interview the complainant and then summon the accused. Before appearing, the team should identify the alleged deception and loss amount in the complaint and prepare explanatory materials by period.

Where there are multiple team members, roles and knowledge may differ. Inconsistent statements among the development lead, marketing staff, and fund manager may adversely affect the entire case, so each person's role and scope of involvement should be organized with objective records.

Fraud can be punished regardless of the victim's wishes. However, restitution is considered in prosecutorial dispositions and sentencing, so the method and timing of refunds or compensation should be reviewed together with their legal implications. Because investors may also pursue civil actions or provisional attachments, the sequence of criminal and civil responses should be coordinated.

6. Implications for Companies

Fraud complaints filed after a token price crash are assessed primarily on the explanations given at the time of fundraising, the feasibility of the project, and the use of raised funds, rather than on the price decline itself. Organizing the drafting history of the white paper and announcements, wallet and account records, and development materials in chronological order is the foundation of the response.

The method of calculating the gain determines whether aggravated penalties apply, and violations of the Virtual Asset User Protection Act as well as confiscation and collection may be considered together. The allocation of roles among team members, restitution negotiations, and the sequence of civil responses should be coordinated early.

Official References

Korea Law Information Center — Criminal Act, Article 347

Korea Law Information Center — Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes, Article 3

Korea Law Information Center — Act on the Protection of Virtual Asset Users, Articles 10, 19 and 20