Unfair Special Terms in Subcontracts: Standards and Contract Review
- 1. Legal Standard for Prohibited Unfair Special Terms
- 2. Key Clauses to Review
- 3. Sanctions and Civil Exposure
- 4. Review Steps When Renewing Master Subcontracts
- 5. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- Is a clause a problem even if the supplier agreed and signed it?
- Is using the standard subcontract form sufficient?
- 6. Implications for Companies
- Relevant Laws
Standards for prohibited unfair special terms in subcontracts and how prime contractors should review their contract forms
Master subcontracts and special terms that prime contractors sign with their suppliers often carry over clauses that shift additional costs, defect liability, or complaint handling expenses to the subcontractor. The Korean Fair Transactions in Subcontracting Act prohibits setting such terms in the first place and sanctions violations with corrective orders and administrative fines.
This review summarizes the legal standard for unfair special terms, the clause types that commonly raise issues, the level of sanctions, and the review steps to take when renewing master subcontracts.
1. Legal Standard for Prohibited Unfair Special Terms
Article 3-4 of the Fair Transactions in Subcontracting Act prohibits a prime contractor from setting contract terms that unfairly infringe on or restrict the interests of the subcontractor, including by requiring matters not stated in the written contract. The Act itself designates as unfair special terms any agreement that shifts to the subcontractor costs arising from requests not stated in the written contract, costs of handling complaints or industrial accidents that the prime contractor should bear, and costs arising from requests not included in the bid details.
Article 6-4 of the Enforcement Decree of the same Act sets out more specific types, including shifting permit, environmental management, and quality control costs that the prime contractor must bear under applicable laws, shifting rework and additional work costs arising from the prime contractor's instructions, and shifting the prime contractor's own defect warranty or damages liability. A violation may be found from the mere setting of such a term, whether or not the cost was actually charged.
2. Key Clauses to Review
| Clause Type | Why It Is a Problem | Revision Direction |
|---|---|---|
| Additional work costs borne by the supplier | One-sided transfer of costs caused by the prime contractor's instructions | Define the scope of instructions, pricing basis, and a written change procedure |
| Complaint and industrial accident costs | A type of unfair special term designated directly by the Act | Allocate costs according to the cause of liability |
| Waiver of design change and price adjustment claims | Restricts in advance the right to request price adjustments guaranteed by law | Reflect statutory adjustment grounds and consultation procedures |
| Unlimited liability for all defects and damages | Broad wording that shifts even the prime contractor's own liability | Specify the scope of fault, period, and cap |
Even when the standard subcontract form is used, the same content often appears separately in special terms, side agreements, site operating guidelines, or the fine print of purchase orders. The review should therefore cover all contract documents.
3. Sanctions and Civil Exposure
Under Article 25-3 of the Fair Transactions in Subcontracting Act, the Korea Fair Trade Commission may impose an administrative fine of up to twice the related subcontract price. Penalty points accumulated through sanctions can lead to restrictions on public procurement bidding or requests for business suspension, and the subcontractor may separately claim damages.
Where the same form has been used for several years, contracts with multiple suppliers may be affected at once.
4. Review Steps When Renewing Master Subcontracts
The first step is collecting the master subcontract, special terms, side agreements, standard purchase order, site guidelines, and bid instructions. Next, clauses on additional work, design changes, complaints, industrial accidents, defects, liquidated damages, and damages are extracted and classified according to whether they shift costs that the prime contractor should bear. Finally, a new form is prepared, amendment agreements are signed for ongoing contracts, and the need to settle any costs already imposed on suppliers is reviewed.
5. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is a clause a problem even if the supplier agreed and signed it?
A signature alone does not take a clause outside the scope of unfair special terms. The content of the clause and the circumstances of the transaction are assessed together.
Is using the standard subcontract form sufficient?
Special terms, annexes, and site guidelines need to be reviewed separately from the main contract.
6. Implications for Companies
Because unfair special terms are assessed on the wording of the contract itself, revising forms before a dispute arises is the most reliable safeguard. Companies should review special terms and purchase orders together when renewing annual master subcontracts or onboarding new suppliers, and, once a complaint or investigation begins, organize the relevant transaction records first to set a response strategy.
Relevant Laws
Korea Law Information Center — Fair Transactions in Subcontracting Act, Articles 3-4 and 25-3

